BoJack tells the production assistant to write all this down. Mr. Peanutbutter says they need to think of someone. In BoJack Hates the Troops, he briefly filmed for a reality show titled Peanutbutter and Jelly. He asks her if she's okay because the other night she left his party crying. Mr. Peanutbutter then announces that the "D" in the Hollywood sign will be replaced. Mr. Peanutbutter celebrates Diane's thirty-fifth birthday with her in After the Party. BoJack explains that the letter is from Hollyhock and he can't open it because he's afraid she'll tell him she never wants to speak to him or see him again. A bitter Katrina tells him while he was gone, Ben Stein introduced her to Tim Allen. However, Todd begins to suggest ideas to Quentin Tarantulino, and is reciprocated due to Tarantulino's eccentricity. Peanutbutter took her fantasy and put structure to it, structure that Diane didn't need or want or influence. Jessica yells at Mr. Peanutbutter for not keeping the mummy away, while also revealing she auditioned to play the actual mummy as she storms off. Around this time, he was married to a woman named Katrina. Joey then wishes Pickles best of luck with the wedding and that he hopes to have what Pickles has with Mr. Peanutbutter. Diane ends up making a fool of herself in front of BoJack, who interrupts her and coldly tells her he's on the phone, as unbeknownst to her his mom was telling him that his father died. Also, in After the Party and What Time Is It Right Now, where he upsets and angers Diane by doing grand gestures for her and giving her elaborate gifts which she tells him countless times throughout their relationship she doesn't like. He tells her they'll talk about this when she comes home. Pickles tells Mr. Peanutbutter the only way for them to be even is if Pickles got to sleep with someone else and Mr. Peanutbutter quickly agrees. Later shows Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter continuing to work on business ventures for PB Livin' they brainstorm on the fly. Diane needs to come to terms with what happened in Cordovia and her PTSD and find treatment for it. Mr. Peanutbutter appears behind him and after BoJack questions why hes here, he explains hes the face of depression, to BoJacks confusion. She states she doesn't want Mr. Peanutbutter to be governor because she thinks he would be bad at it. BoJack finds this annoying and always shoots Mr. Peanutbutter down, although that never stops Mr. Peanutbutter from trying to befriend BoJack. Diane realizes he doesn't want her to go to Cordovia. When Pickles tells Mr. Peanutbutter to take her to the park he agrees. The lawyer informs Todd that it isn't legal and that he'll see him in court. He realizes this the next morning after seeing the 'D' on his deck. He's her cameraman and their relationship quickly spirals into them moving in together. Mr. Peanutbutter loves honeydew, while BoJack hates it. Todd wakes up and learns about the situation. A little while later while Mr. Peanutbutter looks through a script while on the set of Birthday Dad, Princess Carolyn approaches him and shows him a meme she made about Mr. Peanutbutter entitled sad dog" and the different variants of it. Princess Carolyn gets ready to drive over, to help them, while telling them not to enter the house. Eventually, he goes back to the upstairs bedroom not noticing BoJack, Ruthie, Princess Carolyn or Diane, and asks Pickles if she wants whip cream with her drink, not realizing that Pickles was actually in the bathroom and wearing headphones. He sternly tells BoJack "OK, that's enough." Mr. Peanutbutter then realizes that all of his ex's used to be fun, but turned bitter and cruel after being with him but can't figure out the common denominator. Mr. Peanutbutter then says he went to college in Chicago and Diane tells him Northwestern is not in Chicago. The whole "i understand and appreciate you" thing, where they try to fix their marriage, has already been used. Mr. Peanutbutter tries to be tough with them, shoving them into some trash cans, but actually cures them of their ailments. At the desert, an upset Pickles doesn't want to sit on the blanket with Mr. Peanutbutter. In a flashback, Diane and Mr. Peanutbutter have dinner at Elefante and talk about how "[they] are the best divorced couple." They shake hands but before she leaves Mr. Peanutbutter tells her about how he's seeing someone romantically. and pulling BoJack off of her with two other crew members when everyone else either did nothing or filmed the incident. Later that night, Diane and Mr. Peanutbutter toast to their accomplishments, while sitting together in their living room. Not only is he constantly positive, but he is also a bonehead who has difficulty understanding metaphors or puns. Later, Pickles and Joey finish having sex in the meat locker. This almost jeopardized Mr. Peanutbutter's job, as he and Hank both work at MBN, he even looked up to Hank growing up, and he started receiving death threats for Diane. They run past BoJack, who is at the Cinnabunny. In the meat locker, Pickles asks how much longer they have to continue working with Joey. As BoJack is struggling against the crew members, Gina says "What the fuck is wrong with you?" The next morning BoJack wakes up to Mr. Peanutbutter cooking breakfast. Mr. Peanutbutter then walks inside. Diane tells him that's great. After Woodchuck says during a press conference that if a state senator was willing to actually petition for an amendment to the constitution that would democratically allow him to bid his governor title on a ski race, then he would accept the challenge. BoJack then says he's hungry and suggests they go to the diner for lunch. Mr. Peanutbutter says she didn't, and that he loves her and wants to know the real her. Flip yells cut and tells Mr. Peanutbutter that's what real strangling looks like. When Diane and her husband, Mr. Peanutbutter (Paul F. Tompkins), are taken through the mandatory pre-abortion requirements at "Planned Parrothood," the doctor ruthlessly informs them: "By . Mr. Peanutbutter answers the door and enthusiastically says that BoJack can live with him forever. She elaborates, saying that what was part of the betrayal of Mr. Peanutbutter sleeping with Diane, is that they shared an intimate history. Mr. Peanutbutter begins Season 2 by wearing a dog cone, after having to get stitches in his arm after punching a mirror while he was drunk; as he thought his reflection another dog. He leaves, and it's revealed Mr. Peanutbutter heard the whole thing. Princess Carolyn tells him that she needs to get home to her new baby and Mr. Peanutbutter congratulates her on the new baby saying that it could be a movie idea, but Princess Carolyn leaves anyway. Todd bypasses the lawsuit because Walt Disney accidentally wrote down the wrong name for the trademark, "Diisneyland." Mr. Peanutbutter assures her that she should drop it because if something was wrong his brother would tell him. Later, at Elefante, Mr. Peanutbutter tells Pickles he needs to talk to her, which upsets her, but she assures him whatever happensshe wont stop loving him. They hear the doorbell ring. Just then, Mr. Peanutbutter interrupts them. On the set of Birthday Dad, Mr. Peanutbutter is filming a scene and he gets his lines wrong. Pickles reconciles with Mr. Peanutbutter, and Diane leaves, saying she's gonna take someone's helicopter home-seeing that she is unable to reach her car. Mr. Peanutbutter confesses to Joey he isnt really depressed. Flip tells him he's never been to his houseit's supposed to represent how John Philbert feels: spare and lonely. A life of success, wealth, and fame meant Mr. Peanutbutter has never faced any real challenges or had to make difficult decisions, leaving him almost completely inept in the real world. Princess Carolyn prepares to calls a cleaning service, while Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter take care of their foul-smelling clothes. Pickles then thinks it over again. Diane felt pressured to act like she loved parties and socializing and to live up to his "fun" ex-wives, insisting to Mr. Peanutbutter she was having fun when he asked if she was OK. However, he specifies BoJack should bring it up only if the interview is going well. On Mr. Peanutbutter's House, he wore a dark blue collared button-down shirt with a 90s-esque geometric yellow, purple, and teal pattern on it, light blue jeans, brown belt, and white sneakers with Velcro straps. He can be very headstrong and heavily opinionated at times especially in a heated argument to the point of being borderline defensive. After abandoning their first idea of a Halloween store during January, Mr. Peanutbutter throws a large launch party for "Smoodies" (a mood you can drink) at his house without an actual product behind the idea. Unfortunately, the rhino doesn't get mad at Mr. Peanutbutter, but thanks him for getting him to stop smoking. Mr. Peanutbutter goes to WhatTimeIsItRightNow, telling Todd, that Hollywoo producers don't think he's tough enough. Besides his love for tennis balls, he hates the game tennis because he gets angry at how nobody ever catches the ball. She gets upset, as it reminded her he'll never kiss her like that againand drives off crying and heartbroken. 4 years ago Will Diane and Mr. Peanut Butter divorce? BoJack says he's aware. Because Princess Carolyn doesn't give them any candy, thirteen-year-old Todd, Emily and a friend of theirs teepee BoJack's house. He proposes to Diane, and she accepts. He is always trying to reach out to BoJack and be his friend. She says she felt really shitty after he left that night, but when Mr. Peanutbutter assumes he made her feel that way, she rants about how she always feels like garbage. Mr. Peanutbutter explains they are here for a press conference that is on the way to the wedding. While they wait, Todd calls Mr. Peanutbutter and asks him if he should also have Cabracadabra available as a safe space for men, and Mr. Peanutbutter thinks that's a great idea. Mr. Peanutbutter reassures him he will be with him unless he spots his old friend Erica and notices some notable characteristic about her personality, he then questions what the odds of that happening are, making this his final appearance in the series. She tells him as Diane can live her life whole life like pieces of a puzzle from different sets. Princess Carolyn tells him that he isn't tough enough for the role. In fact, it's because of Mr. Peanutbutter's compulsively supportive habits (and questionable intelligence) that BoJack is able to snag his dream role as Secretariat. Mr. Peanutbutter gets ready to talk to the reporters but he is interrupted by Joey telling him about a situation in the kitchen. Mr. Peanutbutter tells Pickles to think of his family because they need him to be strong as his older brother Captain Peanutbutter confessed to him that he feels like hes in a loveless marriage with his wife. He feels guilty about cheating on Pickles, he hasn't told her yet, and tells Diane he was hoping she could break the news to Picklesbecause he's not good at giving bad news and she is. Mr. Peanutbutter tells Pickles that that's just Diane and that she's no fun. She's sad because she thinks things will go back to normal the next day. Diane agrees to this and assures him she's not in New York. Mr. Peanutbutter leaves the house and approaches Pickles. In BoJack Kills Diane heads outside for a smoke break before they leave. ; The Alcoholic: Briefly, after returning from Cordovia and crashing at BoJack's, Diane devolves into a drunken mess as a way to cope with the horrors she saw in the derelict country, fear of confronting Mr. Peanutbutter about the state of their marriage and shame of having "abandoned . She assures him she'll call him if she's out late, and that she's probably not going to have a good time and she's only doing it for work. She continued to be cruel and cold towards Mr. Peanutbutter for the remainder of their marriage. She says knowing the person is what would make them even. She says that he won't always be her only priority. She goes through a brutal divorce with Mr. Peanutbutter, a loving relationship the audience has to watch slowly unravel from season 1 to season 5. Mr. Peanutbutter encourages her to seek out the job opportunity and go on Joey's tour. Joey concludes that there is no way to get in touch and Mr. Peanutbutter says that its too bad, as he would have loved to get together. In short, he is "a dog seen from the point of view of a cat person." Mr. Peanutbutter returns to his kitchen sulking and eats ice cream while not noticing Princess Carolyn and Todd hiding behind his couch. He tells BoJack that when his mom got old they sent her to a farm. He goes outside where his wife Katrina, who's dressed as Blossom, is very cheerful and happily married to him. In Zos and Zeldas, Diane's ex-boyfriend Wayne follows Mr. Peanutbutter as he claims he is writing a Buzzfeed article on him. Paige questions about the boy. It's to just keep yourself busy with unimportant nonsense, and eventually, you'll be dead.Mr. He tells BoJack "all I ever wanted was to be your friend, and you treat me like a big joke.". Joey offers to go into business with him and Mr. Peanutbutter takes the offer. Diane says she isn't happy and that helping people and making a difference with Sebastian St. Clair could give her a reason to get out of bed. Mr. Peanutbutter later calls Diane, who is in Ojai with BoJack, very early in the morning. Although he doesnt completely understand whats going on, he agrees to have sex with Pickles. The changes to the film become increasingly drastic until the film is canceled altogether when Quentin and Todd decide the story should be told as a "bi-monthly curated box of snacks.". However, before celebrating, Mr. Peanutbutter realizes that the red envelope containing the nominations handed to him by Shep Von Trapp was gone. Todd is enthusiastic about the idea, due to being high on marijuana. Pickles reluctantly takes back the ring saying that she supposes they could put it behind them if it only happened one time. Later, Diane asks if they can go soon, because being around so many famous people are making her nervous. Pickles tells Mr. Peanutbutter that the Pickle Pack is a part of everything she does, saying that her subscribers are with her through thick and thin. Diane pretends to still be in Cordovia whenever she calls him. Diane plays along and says she can make it home that night. He says they are both two equally accomplished book writers. Flip tells BoJack that wasn't his intention, he just wants to make a great show, and he's the only one with a problem. He says if she told her that, he would have listened. Before ending the call, Diane makes Mr. Peanutbutter promise not to bother their skunk neighbor, stating that she doesn't want to deal with a stinky husband when she returns home. She cheerfully says it's fine, but starts to sound upset when she talks about his ex-wives and how Diane is here. Also, the house is filled with spaghetti strainers. The wedding is then decided to be held at the restaurant BoJack owns on BoJack's suggestion so he has a better vantage to sabotage the wedding. Pickles is introduced in The Dog Days Are Over in Season 5, where she begins dating Mr. Peanutbutter as his divorce with Diane is being finalized. Mr. Peanutbutter says okay, but she has to come, and she agrees to come if he has the divorce papers. ", BoJack competes on Hollywoo Stars and Celebrities: What Do They Know? Diane then says they are all trying their best. He notes that shaking off made their problem worse, despite the skunk scent being cleared from their bodies. As he and Mr. Peanutbutter leave Princess Carolyn's office, Todd suggests he and Maude go on a double date with Mr. Peanutbutter and Pickles. BoJack and Gina film the nude painting scene, however, they have to cut when Mr. Peanutbutter starts shouting "Oohs" and "Aahs" for support. However, Diane says she so tired of squinting and breaks down crying, as Mr. Peanutbutter looks upset, as an implication their marriage has failed. He also dislikes change, as he didn't want Diane to go to Cordovia. SUB, Mr. Peanutbutter, or "Mr. Chocolate Hazelnut Spread," offers his condolences to BoJack. When Mr. Peanutbutter tries asking Pickles if she heard someone say something, Pickles tells Mr. Peanutbutter not to change the subject and tearfully asks if Mr. Peanutbutter truly cheated on her. He attended Northwestern University. Diane tries to bring it up again but Pickles returns to take their order, starting another conversation with Mr. Peanutbutter, making Diane jealous. Mr. Peanutbutter tells Pickles he can't believe that they've been having this party since 1993, to which Pickles exclaims that was the year she was born. At the same time, people who had arrived at Mr. Peanutbutter's house for the surprise wedding jump out and yell Surprise! but they quickly retreat once Mr. Peanutbutter confesses his adultery, much to Pickles' shock. Flip leaves before BoJack can talk to him, but he says they can talk tomorrow. Mr. Peanutbutter tells them they were thicker than thieves, in fact, they were thievesand tells the reporters about the time BoJack and Sarah Lynn broke into his and Diane's home and stole their clothes. Pickles suggests her high school boyfriend Buzzy. So, why Diane sleep with Mr. Peanutbutter? She leaves, and BoJack swallows a few more pills. In Planned Obsolescence, Mr. Peanutbutter surprises Pickles, by picking her up from work and inviting her to go with him to the desert, so they can watch the international space station being blown up. Spurred on by Margo Martindale at the courthouse to tell Diane his feelings for her, BoJack rushes to the wedding, only to be stopped by an angry Todd telling him to stop intruding in other people's lives. Mr. Peanutbutter tells her that it just looks like he did, and they have to re-edit the scene. Mr. Peanutbutter then tells BoJack he's playing Julius Caesar on the stage next door for a short film. Mr. Peanutbutter sounds shocked at the idea of her sleeping with two people.