This timeline follows the events from the murder to her conviction. Good point about Darins pants. The bottom line is, I feel that Czaban's entire testimony should be taken with a pillar of salt. The state of Texas gave Darlie Routier the trial and verdict they WISHED they could have given Susan Smith. It is a minute, pinprick DOT. Amin Nawabi is an Afghan refugee with a heavy secret he has kept to himself for over 20 years. So many questions too many coincidences. A dog will only bark at an intruder if the dog is aware of his presence. As a private citizen, why cant Teresa Power be heard? THE MURDERS. Here's the problem with that theory: The process of taking photographs and collecting evidence didn't begin until later that morning. On December 28, 1996, Arkansas was found hanging in his cell once againthis time with his hands tied securely in front of him with a bed sheet. Perhaps someone on Darlie's defense team did seek her out and decided her information was not particularly useful; or she may have slipped through the cracks in the shuffle of switching from the court-appointed attorneys. There was also a lack of a blood trail or footprints leading outside of the garage. Darlie is where she belongs. In 2015, parents in Naples, Flordia, started hysteria when they hired Wrinkles the Clown to scare their children straight. In a unique approach to true-crime, facts merge with opinions, mirroring the true confusion surrounding the haunting case. In a unique approach to true-crime,. The CPR is taking place in the Roman room (family room, den, whatever you want to call it), which is toward the back of the house, past the kitchen area. These maggots just eat me alive with these tricks and lies. Cron did not see Darlie's injuries. What if the baby woke up and Darin had to come down and warm up a bottle? For so many, Nickelodeon is the cornerstone of childhood nostalgia. Ive read a lot about this case. The dog and the cats would chase each other around the house, knocking over knickknacks and houseplants, tracking dirt everywhere, etc. What kind of mother has bleached blonde hair and $5,000 breast implants? After 22 years, Darlie Routier remains on death row for son's murder: Part 11 Defense investigators are still working to prove she was not involved in her sons' deaths. In yet another account, she was awoken by the sound of breaking glass. I can understand her anger and frustration at yet another violation of privacy. You're home alone with your teenage daughter, two men try to break in once, come back again with a weapon and break in a different way and you don't call the police? Thanks for commenting. Q. I always laugh when people say all they had to do was pull the screen off, because that wasn't his way. JustinCase976 (author) on December 13, 2019: Darin had said for years that someone should have taken a closer look at the maid since one of the spare keys was missing. I know that someone will likely make the argument that even if Arkansas and Dwayne did break into a house and stab young children in the Dallas area in June of 1996, who's to say that there wasn't a similar crime that was unrelated? My theory is that there was no direct communication between Darin and the assailants; I feel like he would have preferred not to know the details. She was somehow sophisticated enough to think of stabbing herself in her dominant arm, and slit her own throat with her non-dominant hand while standing in front of the sink. What about brown long haired guy - any ID on him? You remember practically every word that Mrs. Routier said to you, but not much that Sergeant Walling said; is that right? I will never believe that he actually stabbed Darlie or the kids, nor do I believe he hired people to kill his family. Darlie picked up the knife without thinking about it and headed back to the family room where she and her young sons had fallen asleep. Ep 07: Darlie Routier was convicted of the 1996 murder of her two small children, Damon and Devon, but she has always adamantly maintained her innocence. Expert testimony typically plays well with juries, but a considerable amount of the analysis presented during Darlie's trial was problematic at best. This is the one point that people seem to have the most difficulty with. And for Beatles fans? To believe she is the killer, I would have to believe in one of two scenarios: Even back in 1996 and 1997, I personally was never convinced of Darlie's guilt. The presence of blood and water alone does not indicate a cleanup job, in my opinion. There was no valid reason for this; these nurses did not attend to Damon or Devon and would not be testifying about their injuries or autopsies. Q. She told the dispatcher that she and her two sons had been stabbed. Hmmmm. Of course, she didn't do that, because she knew full well the baby was fine. This caused the prosecution to claim that Darlie placed it there to further enhance evidence of a struggle. The Beatles: Eight Days a Week The Touring Years, Do you remember where you were when the world shut down in March 2020? The software will then compare that print to all other prints stored in the database. He didn't bark because he was never aware those people were in the house. Darlie's bloody footprints were photographed underneath some of the glass, causing them to believe she broke the glass after the fact to make it look like there had been a struggle. TWELVE DAYS! There is a chapter in that book that struck me like lightning, and I couldn't get it out of my mind. I really don't think there's any substance to that theory, and I believe this avenue has been explored with no success. She grabbed a butcher knife and just started stabbing her kids in a rage. There are no photos of the Routier sink after Luminol was applied. Darlie was given the death penalty for these murders. Austyn Tester is a 16-year-old internet sensation, longing to escape his dead-end life in rural Tennessee. figueroa street shooting; jeffrey friedman chiropractor; gifted child humming; how to adjust sim max driver; darlie routier documentary hulu. My response to that: "Only if you completely ignore everything presented by the defensewhich only a fool would do.". Therefore, Darlies execution date has not yet been set, and she, maintaining her innocence, is incarcerated at the Mountain View Unit in Gatesville, Texas. Dead Asleep is a true-crime documentary surrounding Randy Herman, Jr. and the murder he committed while he was fast asleepor so he claims. Rickels would not actually contact police with this information until June 11th, five days after the murders. Dr. Phil is a non-factor and is about as useful as tits on a bull. In the years that have followed, Darlie has filed two appeals on the grounds of alleged irregularities during her trial, but they have been denied. is a TV docuseries about two former Mormon wives who found the courage to leave the church and their husbands so they can live a life true to themselves. That's funny, Laurie! Is a scam with good intentions still a scam? This includes various locations across Spain, Italy, and France, all three of which are iconic filming locations that are fairly commonplace in modern cinema and TV. If the two police officers did not see this laying in the middle of the kitchen, it wasn't there. A lot of people doubt that Darin was actually planning a burglary scam; they say he just made that up to help with Darlie's appeal. Do you love sports documentaries? She was never charged with the murder of her other son, six-year-old Devon. Thank's Adele. Rickels turned on the bedroom light and once again, the men ran off. She turned on the lights to find that she and her children had been stabbed and were soaked in blood, thus beginning the worst nightmare and biggest fight of her life. The media circled her like sharks, and, eventually, she was sentenced to death-row. A short time later, he was fully awakened by the sound of Darin yelling. His car out - her car in street - big kids downstairs- doesnt hear a struggle - lost pants - ran across street- and more.. maybe he was the only one that actually knew that THEY WOULD BE HOME???? No one was concerned with trying to preserve a crime scene; the priority was to treat the injured. One replied that he did not; the other replied he remembered seeing it, but wasn't sure if it was there when he first came in or if it was later when he did a walk through. Here's a little piece of that cross-examination that didn't receive nearly as much media time as the rest: Q. Poor Darlie ? Darlie's Injuries It was the Prosecution's case that on the 6th of June, Darlie stabbed her two boys to death and then went to the sink in the kitchen and slashed her throat and cut her arm over the sink. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. What is the oldest unsolved cold case? so as Darlie the monster the prosecution. The media circled her like sharks, and, eventually, she was sentenced to death-row. I tend to agree with you as far as a mother going upstairs to check on the baby; in a situation like that, I can't picture leaving my dying children even for a second. Watch on your TV, laptop, phone, or tablet. I'm not saying it's impossible for his kicking to have caused that bruising, but it is improbable. and the part about Darlie and the babysitter rebecca laughing when Drake was starting to fall from the couch? But it may not have to go that far. This is the same officer, by the way, who neglected to collect several bloody towels as evidence, but for some reason retrieved as evidence paperwork on a funeral and headstone for a cat that had died the previous summer. True Crime. The Curse of Von Dutch: A Brand to Die For is a documentary that chronicles the unbelievable dark story behind the rise and fall of the once iconic brand. Incidentally, the song begins with a Bible verse, does not contain one single obscenity, and preaches a strong anti-gang and violence message. When he told her, she openly challenged him and asked if that was illegal. Did Darlie do it? His testimony states: "I thought if she was worried about fingerprints on a knife, she could certainly take care of her kids." Next up is an expert who was never called to testify: Dr. Kenneth Dekleva, the state's own forensic psychiatrist. It should be noted here that at the end of the 911 call, somewhere between 2:36 and 2:37 am, the dispatcher tells Darlie there is a police officer at her door and to let him in. Viewers of The Last Defense, co-produced by actress Viola . Darlie's blood was found to have dripped onto it, and there were wheel marks where it appeared the vacuum had been rolled through wet blood. The inmate is identified only as "Karl," but the contents of the letter were a bombshell. According to Jovell, I believe she said the accomplice was a friend of her daughter's and that they took the car to a farm in Oklahoma to hide it. It is my understanding that recent testing of the night shirt revealed an unknown DNA profile. Three days later, she was sentenced to death by lethal injection. I think every last juror saw every last one of those pictures. June 6, 1996. When Karl learned her name, and the fact that her children had been stabbed to death in June of 1996, he put two and two together. Maybe youre looking for a music doc like, Or, maybe youre ready to take a nostalgic deep dive with a 90s doc like, Dont think we forgot about you, true crime junkies. Can a murder committed while sleepwalking be criminally charged? Nope, try again. At 19 years old, the brothers learned of each other for the first time, uncovering the harrowing truth behind their separation. What the prosecution does not say is that there was no evidence of Devon's blood present on the knife that was recovered from the Routier home; only Damon's and Darlie's blood were present. The sock had drops of Devon's and Damon's blood on it, but none of Darlie's blood. Presented by Ahmir Questlove Thompson, Summer of Soul is part music film and part Black history documentary. Internal job & corruption = recipe for a death row disaster. I read the transcripts. From. For me, Im so excited!!!!!! He did not become fully awake, nor did he look at the clock. I am not responsible for what other supporters say, but I at no time ever stated that her necklace was embedded into her wound, nor did I say it had to be surgically removed. Under Toby Shook's brutal cross-examination, Darlie became non-responsive, argumentative, and even downright angry. 7) Blood under the glass and vacuum--now we're getting somewhere. Darlie's eldest son, Devon, had already died from four knife wounds. Arkansas was known for his quick violent temper and substance abuse issues. After putting Darlie in jail with bail set at $1 million, the state of Texas placed baby Drake in a foster home in 1996. I honestly have no idea. They found DNA from a black male on the sock found in the ally. Darlier Routier Not Gone with the Wind. Director Alexander Nanau follows a team of newspaper investigators as they work to expose a case of extreme health care fraud in Romania that has been lining the pockets of business executives and politicians while killing innocent civilians. What if Gorsuch was still awake and happened to see her running outside to plant this sock? Feet US Of Clay Poster (1924) US Insert Movie Clay Poster ! Keep This Between Us is a documentary that exposes a horrifying epidemic of high school teachers grooming their studentstold through the lens of a female victim and her relationship with a teacher she once trusted. Quinncy was intrigued enough to start doing some digging. Out of all the things that non-supporters say, that takes the cake as the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Another thing i would like to mention the police accused the clean up at the kitchen sink when they sprayed luminol. Darins pants are a problem. A guy like you would keep an accurate clock, wouldn't he? "Ma'am, I need you to talk to me." Did you see my comment about the kitchen sink clean up ? So please forgive me for not taking those transcripts as the holy grail of this case. You will never get me to believe that Darlie threw a glass to simulate a struggle for the simple fact that I know someone rounded a corner and walked smack dab into the wine rack, shattering a glass while it was still in place in its holder. See his direct examination testimony from the August 26, 1996, hearing of a motion to hold Darlie without bail below (most important lines bolded): Q. He reiterated the time during cross-examination, and was adamant that his clock is set for the actual, precise time, and not a few minutes fast as some people are prone to do. He also wrote to Houston attorney and former investigative reporter Quinncy McNeal, who was also named in the article, relating the same story. Patterson. The band you know, and the story you dont. Darlie's first words to the dispatcher were: Somebody came herethey broke in! I know the police wanted his bloody clothing while he was at the hospital, and he was given scrubs to wear. I really hope the whole truth comes out, sooner rather than later. Did Darlie get a fair trial? She asked repeatedly when the ambulance would arrive. Nabors Dirty deeds done dirt cheap. , has been a taboo word in American culture for decades. To eliminate this problem, they simply brought the dog into their room every night when they went to bed. He would have had to be in the house for all that time until the cop got there, what was he doing hanging around the crime scene? It would have to be proven that: the witness knowingly gave false testimony; this testimony had a direct influence on the court decisions and/or verdict; and that the prosecution was aware of the false nature of the testimony--which even I have to concede that they may not have been. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. Moving him in any way could have resulted in permanent paralysis, had he lived. This is good for Darlie in the sense that it adds yet another element of doubt regarding her story of an intruder. The band you know, and the story you dont. Blood under glass & vacuum. It can be reasonably assumed that his reply is affirmative, since she immediately becomes even more hysterical and screams, "Oh my God!". documentary that follows three young men who bond over skateboarding to escape their turbulent home lives in the Rust Belt of America. Slay the Dragon follows political activists fighting to terminate gerrymandering from the United States election process. Ultimately, on February 1, 1997, Darlie was convicted for the murder of her 5-year-old son, Damon. The murders were premeditated, meaning Darlie chose to do this in the middle of the night, with Darin at home and just upstairs. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Inappropriate, he thundered. I stepped over, to look into the garage, just to see if I could see anybody, and told her to apply some pressure to the first child's wounds. Glenn Mize was the only person Darlie could think of that she had a problem with, and Gary Austin's own wife threw him under the bus as a person of interest. Is this what you do when you are the one who has stabbed your own children, and one of them is still alive and could possibly identify you as the one who attacked him? She was first tried in the media, then she was tried in the court of public opinion, and, finally, she was tried in a courtroom. It made them want someone to be punished and added a degree of hostility toward Darlie in their testimony. So here's my challenge to you: Find me proof of such a crime. Darlie Lynn Peck was born on January 4, 1970 in Altoona, Pennsylvania. This means that Damon had to have been stabbed within about a minute before the 911 call began. I hear new DNA coming her way. Arkansas suicide with hands in front? I can understand that, except that I'm at the opposite end of the spectrum. Some of these errors were minor; many were not. Ah that makes a comment I saw on Facebook make sense now. Transport back to the summer of 69 in this powerful and important story that celebrates Black music, culture, and fashion at the iconic Harlem Cultural Festival. Cold Case Files is a reality legal show/documentary on the cable channel A&E Network and the rebooted series on Netflix. Maybe one of them jumped on her while she was on the couch and they began fighting. What Darlie initially relayed to the police, her family, and the media was most likely disjointed fragments of memories assembled to the best of her ability. SMH. Q. There's always a part of you that's on alert, waiting for a whimper or cry that signals it's time to warm up a bottle or grab a fresh diaper. This fingerprint did not match one single person who was known to be in the house that night; it did not belong to any of the Routiers, nor did it match any of the police officers or paramedics (all were printed to rule them out). Darlie's story was also featured. Well, if there was, I can't find a record of it. In truth, Darlie did not pick the music and did not know the song would be played, but the jury did not hear this. And if this is where Darlie cut her throat and stabbed herself in the arm, where is all the castoff blood? I see a judge with a clear bias in favor of the prosecution that was blatantly trying to rush through the trial, never mind that someone's life was hanging in the balance. She has also been widely criticized for not calling the police that night. Darlie does not need Dr. Phil for worldwide attention--she already has it. What about road rage incidents? We hear a desperate mother who was in shock, begging for help. is a true-crime documentary surrounding Randy Herman, Jr. and the murder he committed while he was fast asleepor so he claims. Darlie spent two days in the hospital recovering from her injuries, whereas her sons died. He was the one that actually put the bandage on you and walked you out? The public Facebook page for Darlie just locked down - accepting no new members. I have no doubt that Diane Downs shot her children and then shot herself in the arm. At the time of the. Waddell's response was that he did not; Walling stated that he did remember seeing it, but wasn't sure if it was there when he first came in, or if it was there later when he did a walk-through. If you're going to plant evidence to throw police off your trail, why not leave it in the yard or somewhere closer to the house where it is more likely to be found? I'm actually glad that you addressed that, Rachael. Its results, though, are currently pending, from what we can tell. Thank you kindly for the compliment. I've looked, believe me. is the horrifying story of Harvey Weinsteins abuse of power, told by the women who suffered physical and mental abuse caused at his hand. No, she most certainly didn't. She is on death row after courts convicted her of murdering one of her sons, while standing accused of killing the other. She had suffered a stroke during childbirth the previous fall, she had cardiac issues and was treated for three minor heart attacks during the summer of 1996; plus, she had recently lost her brother and had been prescribed the anti-depressant Trazadone. Glass remained in the wine rack, proving that this glass was not broken by being thrown to the floor. JustinCase976 (author) on February 28, 2020: I didn't know that but that definitely raises an eyebrow. Would Darlie walk? Darin and Darlie purchased the house toward the end of 1992 and moved in at the beginning of 1993. On the nights when Darlie would sleep on the couch, that wasn't an issue. Nonsense. The media circled her like sharks, and, eventually, she was sentenced to death-row. According to the prosecution, Darlie cut her own throat while standing at the sink, and then attempted to clean it up. What was he a suspect for, a whole 2 hours? So he and his thug drug friends have to be involved. JustinCase976 (author) on December 16, 2019: You may very well be right. JustinCase976 (author) on March 11, 2020: I would bet money that the Texas authorities already have someone under investigation. When questioned about the time at which this took place, Gorsuch testified during direct examination that he looked at the clock and it was 2:40 am. 20 years later, doubt still remains. In the crime scene photo below, you can clearly see that a shard of glass remains in the holder where the broken glass had been. It's part of an all-out push by the Innocence Project to try and prove Routier did not kill her two boys in 1996. There was no investigation of Darin. If you don't, I can't help you. Because the first guy brought his own knife, which is what he used to cut the screen (we'll get to the bread knife later). ABC Docu-series "The Last Defense" episodes 1-4. Darlie Routier (DMN File) By. I just figured, you know, what can the police do now?" No, I don't feel as if the nurses were part of a conspiracy. She claimed that an intruder had broken into her home and stabbed her two sons, Devon and Damon, as well as herself. They were youngDarin was 28 and Darlie was 26and they were enjoying the money they were making. Darlie told police that she heard the sound of breaking glass, and there were glass fragments strewn about the kitchen floor area. Can you show me ANY picture of him crushed by this major catastrophic event in his life. ", Karen said, "They said they broke into a house and it all went bad. 5) Yes, the knife came from her house. Karl was never able to pick out the other man, but sent a note back to Quinncy with one of the mugshots: "This is Arkansas.". She was tried for the murder of her youngest son, 5-year-old Damon, found guilty, and, on February 4, 1997, sentenced to death. Nothing happens overnight; it's all a process. Take a deep dive into the chaotic rise and fall of Adam Naumanns company, WeWork a series of co-working spaces he believed would change the world. DUH. Thats what Id say hang on a sec while I change. A liar already has their story prepared in their mind. It is in the toxicology report, but Greg Davis lied and would not turn over the results to th edefense during the trial. is a documentary that focuses on an Oakland area high school, bringing students real-life struggles to light and how the pandemic has only made them worse. Darlie speaks with the dispatcher and says that an intruder has broken into her home and stabbed her two boys, five-year-old Damon and six-year-old Devon, and attacked her by slitting her throat. Last but not least, the amount of fiber recovered from the knife was so minuscule that when Linch was finished with his analysis, there was nothing left for the defense to perform their own analysis! According to Karen, in early June of 1996, Arkansas, Dwayne, and a third man "got into a fight about drugs" and took a road trip headed for Dallas in a stolen white truck. In fact, why would you call 911 at all unless you were sure they were both dead? The 1993-built Routier home has 2,740 square feet with three bedrooms and three baths. Its very unique. Karl sat down and promptly wrote to Darlie, sharing this information with her. I did want your opinion on this and makes sense what you say. She was convicted of Damon's murder on February 4, 1997 and has been on Texas' death row since then. He would have had to have been kicking her arms for half an hour straight to cause that kind of bruising. My gut instinct was always that she was innocent and had been railroaded, which I thought was a crying shame, but then I would go about my business and forget about her for a while, until my attention would be drawn to it again for whatever reason. He was treated, evaluated, and it was determined that he was not a serious suicide risk. Menu Let's say that Waddell is correct when he says that he saw a man come out of the front door and into the front yard when he first pulled up. He may have been an experienced police officer, but he was still a parent, and I believe the man just plain froze. Why do they have to do that if they're so confident in her guilt? Darlie later added, Im at peace with myself I did not murder my children, I did not attack myself. The detectives were not called by the state to testify; it was the defense that put them on the stand. Where is Darin Routier Now? Did this seemingly happy housewife and mother commit this brutal act or did tunnel vision taint the investigation from the start? Did you ever tell her to do that after Sergeant Walling arrived? In Darlie's case, she probably subconsciously realized there had been more than one person, but since she only has a memory of seeing one of them, her confusion is understandable. Check out these true crime documentaries streaming now on Hulu. All right. She had nothing to do while in jail but rack her brain and agonize over the fact that her children's killer was walking around free while she sat in jail, on trial for her very life. I believe you're right on the money as far as why it looked like there was "clean up" in the sink area. Some people swear they have, other people say it's a load of crap. It should be noted that not every nurse who treated Darlie was called to testify. The spectators got a good chuckle at her expense when Shook replied scathingly that it was not. But prior to going to the hospital, I thought he was given clothes to wear from Terry Neal across the street. It's tempting to assume that's what we would have said in her position. She actually named a couple of different suspects in her letters. In early 1998, Karl was in jail reading The New Yorker magazine when he came upon an article about the impending execution of Karla Faye Tucker. If anyone ever looks at it all they'll see is "did you really think I'd be dumb enough to write anything personal? That may have been part of the problem, but the biggest nail in the coffin was a downright dirty trick pulled by the prosecution. All of them, most likely. Moreover, one of the cuts Darlie sustained came within millimeters of a major artery, and no one would ever really do so purposefully. He's a wealthy businessman from Waco who hired his own investigators to look into the case. Theres plenty more where that came from. is a story about a pool boy in Miami that finds himself caught in a scandalous affair with the Falwellsa prominent family in the Christian community. When you think of the creator of Batman, you probably think of Bob Kane. She suffered the trauma of having been awakened by an intruder who slit her . Somethings up. Very few pop culture phenomenons have stood the test of time or have made a societal impact quite like Barbie. At the time, Darlie had two different private investigators working on the case and feeding her (sometimes conflicting) information. Investigators (and guilters) claim that Darlie's bloody footprints under the broken glass on the floor is further evidence of a staged crime scene. If so, its still the murders and attack unsolved. Court reporter Sandra Halsey pled the 5th when questioned about the errors in the trial transcripts and the missing audio tapes.