He would get on the airplane on Saturdays, put on earphones and not talk to anybody. While we haven't heard directly from Rodgers throughout this saga, Favre said on ESPN's Wilde & Tausch show Wednesday he texted No. During the 2017 offseason, Rodgers went a solid month without throwing a footballthe most time hes taken off from throwing that he can remember. Other than his early career decision to sport a mustache, Rodgers' decision-making is pretty good. The problem with George is that his gifts are fairly one-note. I told Ted, 'This guy Rodgers is special. Before the gear was packed and the flights arranged, Rodgers had one last exchange with Tomlinson, the reporter who, months earlier, warned him about the ensuing nightmare. Use without license or authorization is expressly prohibited. Hes also thrown 368 consecutive passes without being picked off, which is a new NFL record. And finally, the absence of quality video from before 1995 is glaring. This chart is based on the number of years they started at least half a season. With little to do but improve while sitting behind Favre, Rodgers added the extra muscle that makes him one of the strongest throwers in the NFL today. When the day arrived and the Utah junior was selected No. Super Bowl Tailgate Party Stink Sez Stay Home! His confidence came into play other times when he held onto the ball too long, thinking he could make a play out of nothing when he should've just gotten rid of it. Come back daily for basketball training videos and drills from some of the nations top basketball programs and advice from professional coaches and trainers. "Boy it's a good question; that's the million-dollar question," Favre said during an interview Wednesday on ESPN Wisconsin radio's Wilde & Tausch. Rodgers earned NFL MVP honors again in 2014. Its just my legs, maybe, are feeling a little bit better than the last couple years. Rodgers told ESPN in 2017. So robotic. Youre a first-round pick, Aaron, he said. People felt loyal to Brett, because in Green Bay he was a football God, Tomlinson said. I know wins is a bad statbut Tom Brady . Before the 2005 NFL Draft (where the Packers selected Rodgers with the 24th overall pick), one anonymous NFC scout told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel that Tedford-tutored quarterbacks were too well-schooled. Id almost believe you if the Jets hadnt revamped their entire roster via free agency in the offseason by signing possibly the best guard in the NFL Alan Faneca. If Brett Favre is right about Aaron Rodgers' future, this is going to be a big reason why. Rodgers is a little bit better at this because he's a dual threat. As Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers continues to feign general ignorance as to the necessity of a decision about his future, there's a very specific path he potentially could take. I wanted cohesion for the franchise, he said. Check out this rocket from Green Bays 2002 victory over the Bears in Champaign, Ill. Sixty yards on a dime, and Favre puts so much oomph into it that he nearly falls over. First, it puts me in a better position to make an informed conclusion. But what followedstrange. Favre has thrown for over 71k yards while Rodgers has thrown for almost 47k yards. i could watch Brett Favre highlights every day and never get bored pic.twitter.com/6jiKD49uMF. You want your feet in a positive position. Bart Starr, Brett Favre, and Aaron Rodgers make up the best franchise QB trio in NFL . In addition to STACKs wrestling workouts, we also provide plenty of nutrition advice to help wrestlers make and maintain weight throughout their training. Subscribe to The Athletic for in-depth coverage of your favorite players, teams, leagues and clubs. ', When the Oakland Raiders grabbed a Nebraska cornerback named Fabian Washington with the 23rd selection, Thompson knew immediately who the Packers would take. When you signed with Green Bay, there was no false illusion you were there to fight Brett for a job, said Akili Smith, the Bengals first-round pick in 1999 who attended camp with the Packers four years later. A couple of weeks after the draft, Dylan Tomlinson of Gannett Wisconsin Newspapers was sent 90 miles northeast of Sacramento to Chico, California, to visit with Aaron Rodgers for a profile. He had great arm strength, he was very mobile, he had an extremely quick release, very bright guy," Favre recalled. Both of these players are leaders. At the time of this writing, Rodgers has 23 passing touchdowns to just one interception on the season. 5. The body control that he displayed to deliver throws to every level of the field from any platform and his penchant for plunging a sword into the hearts of Bears fans everywhere turned him into an almost mythical creature. Favre vs. Rodgers: Career Stats Comparison. Three years into Rodgers' tenure in Green Bay, he guided the Packers to the 2010 Super Bowl title over the Pittsburgh Steelers and earned . When it came down to it, the game lived and died by No.4. If he wanted to miss a practice? Favre owns a 12-10 postseason mark with the Packers while Rodgers is 11-8. You know, thatone guy who leads the entire NFL in passing TD while maintaining anearly 3 to 1 TD to INT ratio? It was ThompsonHow do you feel about coming to Green Bay?, Before rising to shake Tagliabues hand, Rodgers was grabbed by Merton Hanks, a former Pro Bowl cornerback now employed by the NFL. Howd he manage such a turnaround? In the 230 contests in his career, Rodgers has been successful on 5,001 of his 7,660 attempts for 59,055 yds. His actions back up this philosophy. As Favre's popularity decreased in Wisconsin, his replacement, Aaron Rodgers, gained approval at a similar pace. Madden 22 ranks Allen of the Buffalo Bills on the top list. I'm wondering how people on here would categorize the arm strength of various Hall of Fame QBs, and other known QBs over the year. With Doug Pederson now retired, Nall served as Favres primary sidekick, and the two southern boys talked about Rodgers like two bullies mocking a math club nerd. Rodgers surely recognized the mistake as soon as the words emerged from his lips. Every NFL fan tends to go bonkers about QB stats and each athletes place in history. He seemed to believe he was not only ready for the NFL, but ready to lead the Packers. Train for wrestling with workouts that provide the explosive strength and power you need to take down an opponent. When you can execute every throw, theres no reason not to try every throw. Rodgers just threw the ball. Others, like OBrien and Couch, arrived and departed with barely a shadow. To hear Rodgers tell it, his right arm itself isnt actually all that important. Do something! he pleaded. His shoulders can be parallel to the line of scrimmage, and the whiplash created by his arm can still get enough mustard on the ball to get it where it needs to go. EDITOR'S NOTE:In this excerpt from Jeff Pearlman's upcoming release,GUNSLINGER: The Remarkable, Improbable, Iconic Life of Brett Favre,the story picks up as thelegendary Packers quarterback has finished a disappointing 10-6 regular season and a Wild Card Game loss to the division-rival Minnesota Vikings. I watched [former Ravens quarterback] Kyle Bollers Cal workout, and he got on his knees at the 50 and threw one over the goalpost. Rodgers, though, kept moving, kept running, kept looking. There was this awkward tension in the room. When the meeting ended, Nall apologized to Rodgers, but advised him to relax. Aaron Rodgers, 2005-present When people compare Favre and Rodgers (who've somehow held down the Packers ' starting QB job for the past 28 years ), I think it's easy to get distracted by how . Seriously, Rodgers said, I dont even have his number., With a young roster featuring 11 rookies, the year was destined to be a struggle. Later that day, Rodgers spoke via conference call with the Green Bay media. Favre said he felt the pressure mounting once Rodgers joined the team and threatened his job. And I couldnt be happier with what next year, and the years to come, will look like. Rodgers scored a 1310 on the SATs and graduated Pleasant Valley High with an A- average. Now hopefully he watches me and gets something from that., From that first day, Favre did nothing to help Rodgers and much to hurt and ridicule him. Rodgers has completed 350 of his 542 throws for a completion percentage of 64.6%. Say what you will about arm strength, but Pennington is smart enoughto not throw the ball into double and triple coverage the way Favre does. And thats what matters. Favre is tougher. Today, the two are good friends, talk regularly, and have even discussed the irony of the Green Bay Packers drafting Jordan Love in a similar scenario to what started the pairs frosty relationship 15 years ago. Stathead: Baseball's Most Powerful Search Tool, Stathead: Basketball's Most Powerful Research Tool, Stathead: Football's Most Powerful Research Tool, Stathead: Hockey's Most Powerful Research Tool, Watch our How-To Videos to Become a Stathead, Subscribe to Stathead and get access to more data than you can imagine. Now merely a head coach (and a disgruntled one at that), Sherman allowed Favre to skip the workouts, but that didnt mean he would not attend. Even as Favre crept into his 40s during his stint with the Vikings, he was still throwing the ball hard enough to knock over his receivers. source for the material. Favre's got it. If it was his turn in the quarterback rotation and he saw me at wide receiver, hed wave Rodgers in instead of throwing to me. He totaled 237.9 yds per contest through the air with a 86.0 quarterback rating. At 6 feet 5 inches, 225 pounds, Love is the prototype of the modern, mobile quarterback and is blessed with great arm strength. MJ and Heres Why. It wasnt always this way. OK. Brett Favre. Favre was 2-3 in NFC championship games, and that included a 2-2 record with the Packers. I think Allen is a terrible prospect, but we can't deny his arm is historically great. Rodgers finished 95 of 143 (66.4 percent) with 11 TDs and three interceptions. This kind of separates into two different categories: theability to extend the play with your feet andthe actual ability to pick up yards on the ground. Tampa Bays starting quarterback was the mediocre Brian Grieseand they selected a halfback, Auburns Cadillac Williams, fifth. He also threw the most interceptions in NFL history (336). Favrefinished 1-1 in Super Bowl appearances. You want to transfer power from the ground, to your hips, to your shoulders, to your release point. One of them was an inconsistency on deep balls. Those throws against Cover 2 were a staple of the NFL during the back half of Favres career, but theres a significant difference between the way Peyton Manning hit them and the way Favre would. Where was Reggie White? Rodgers sat for a few years behind Favre while McCarthy & Co. helped adjust his grip, giving him a faster, more fluid delivery. Also Favre has almost 150 more TDS than Rodgers does with 508 and 364 respectively. GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN - SEPTEMBER 15: Aaron Rodgers #12 of the Green Bay Packers shares a moment with former quarterback Brett Favre during a ceremony for the late Bart Starr at halftime of the . Sweet. Instead, he focused on building lower-body strength and stability. No QB in the history of football has been able to harness that power quite like Rodgers. Aaron Rodgers will be in Canton once his playing days are over. Rodgers' mechanics left a lot to be desired . Jim Hart's passes allegedly left a "vapor trail." If that isn't an indication of his pure arm strength, the St. Louis Cardinals legend was also rumored to have completed a 98-yard pass in the air. When it came to the actual judging, several different criteria were taken into account. No QB Rodgers included has routinely produced more highlights per play during his first few seasons as a starter. I played my whole career with a chip on my shoulder, Hanks whispered. Youll find the basketball workouts and drills youre looking for to take your game to the next level. Harlan was, however, never comfortable with such a consolidation of power, and grew increasingly concerned as Sherman blew high draft picks on busts and floundered in drawing free agents. You throw the football from the ground up. As part of this process, I surveyed a few football buffs that I trust, and multiple people immediately brought up Jeff George. Of all the honorable mentions, Stafford was the closest to cracking the top tier. Robert previously covered the NFL and hosted podcasts for Grantland, The Ringer and The MMQB. Basketball is a fast-paced sport that requires explosive strength, top speed, agility and fine-tuned on-court skills. This website uses cookies and third party services. That isnt Aaron Rodgers fault. Tom Brady VS Aaron Rodgers; When compared to former quarterback Chris Simms, he has a 10.50-inch arm span. 4,002 passing yards 26 touchdowns 4 interceptions (led NFL in INT %)Watch @AaronRodgers12's 2019 season highlights.#GoPackGo pic.twitter.com/d7lBfgNZ7i. Everything about the way he moves is compact, with almost all of his power coming from the way he creates torque with his hips and upper body. The Cheapest & Most Expensive NBA Teams to Watch in 2022-23, Tyler Huntley Status Confirms Pro Bowl As Complete Joke, Immaculate Reception at 50 Thru The Eyes of Terry and Franco, How Big Is Zach Edey? Because he played quarterback for an off-the-map school in an off-the-map corner of California, Rodgerswho threw for 4,421 yards in two seasons as a prep starterreceived no Division I scholarship offers. Favre and Rodgers are among the eight players with multiple NFL MVP awards. Rodgers, who will turn 36 in December, has 20, three less than Russell Wilson. From New Englands 1-yard line, Mahomes took a shotgun snap, drifted to his left, and dropped a rainbow to Hill in the back corner of the end zone. As mentioned earlier, he's patient and doesn't normally try to force the ball into coverage unless absolutely necessary. The morning after the news, Nall arrived at the facility with a copy of an image someone had e-mailed him, featuring a person in a shirt reading ALL DADDY WANTED WAS A BLOW JOB. Brett Favre was 35 when the Packers drafted 21-year-old Aaron Rodgers with a first-round draft choice in 2005. . Though but 21, he was clearly more intelligent and probing than Favre. He handled himself perfectly, especially when asked about the incumbent. It had been a while since Id gone back and watched Favre play. Brett Favre said he doesn't think Aaron Rodgers will finish his career with the Green Bay Packers. And they were like, Whyd we draft this guy? Rodgers got payback in 2010 with a pair of head-to-head victories that launched Green Bay's last Super Bowl run. Smith was quiet. But Bledsoe is not in the conversation with any of these guys. For all his power, Rodgers typically has to get his left shoulder pointed in the proper direction to deliver on-target throws. For years, Ive said that Rodgers isnt a mortal human being. The fact remains, Favre is his prime was the gold standard for football launching. But, out of friendship, he made the trip. But there was no taking it back. Derek Hagan? The only thing that rivaled that was the Super Bowl a few years later. In his 15-year career thus far, Rodgers has earned two All-Pro honors and made eight Pro Bowl appearances. Shortly before the draft, for example, a scout for an NFC team told Pete Dougherty of the Green Bay Press-Gazette that he would pass on Rodgers. I asked Rodgers afterward if he was surprised Brett didnt offer any help. Those two quarterbacks have combined for almost 30 years of success in Green Bay with Hall of Fame-caliber quarterback play, and the comparisons will continue long after Rodgers ultimately retires. Terry Bradshaw: In his day, the Steelers quarterback made some perfectly prolific deep balls that left fans gasping. Three running backs, three wide receivers and three cornerbacks rounded out the Top 10. With his baseball background, Mahomes uses that arm in a way no other great QB does. That opportunity comes with a matchup againsttheTampa BayBuccaneersat 3:05 p.m. on Sunday. Predicted 2023 Fitness and Wellness Trends- Not Your Usual Trends! Seven weeks later, he hit on a mere 14 of 29 attempts (with two interceptions) as the Ravens smothered Green Bay, 48-3. (Photo of Brett Favre: Brian Bahr /Allsport via Getty Images). Favre won the award three consecutive years from 1995-97. There's a reason why Aaron Rodgers only wanted to throw to 2 players. Through STACK, youll find the explosive workouts, conditioning and full-body strength training you need to get bigger, faster and stronger on the lacrosse field. At this point, Mahomes makes the incredible look forgettable, and thats the ultimate compliment for any QB. Aaron Rodgers career vs. Brett Favre career. He looked at it for 10 seconds and dropped it to the floor, said Nall. "My last year in Green Bay, statistically speaking, was the best year I had in 16 years with the Packers," Favre explained . Favre had . It was like, Grandpa? Their relationship aside, on the field as of this moment with Rodgers still playing and his legacy incomplete, which one is better Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers? Rodgers was the butt of jokessome that he heard, many that he did not. Rodgers' 110.4 passer rating for the season currently leads the NFL as he makes a . While Favres INT to TD ratio is almost 1 to 1, Rodgers is one TD shy of 2 to 1 and hes thrown 25 more passes. Ill pray on it. A decade earlier Tom Rossley, the Packers offensive coordinator, had been the head coach at Southern Methodist. The Green Bay Packers have been blessed to have three of the greatest signal-callers ever play for them. One day in a quarterbacks meeting he said, Brett, what did you get on it?, I do, Rodgers said. Rodgers became the fifth quarterback since the NFL-AFL merger to make five conference championship appearances. Rodgers won Super Bowl MVP honors. Back in 1991 he lasted into the fifth round before being picked by San Francisco. Then, Patrick Mahomes came along. Check out STACKs workouts and drills tailored specifically for hockey players. You also have to look at the amount of TDs and yards each has thrown. The Culpepper-Randy Moss connection is one of the more underrated QB-receiver duos in recent memory, but the formers downfield accuracy still wasnt quite enough to push the best guys on this list. Rodgers told me last year that the hardest pass of his career came on a TD pass to Jordy Nelson in the 2010 divisional round against Atlanta on a throw moving to his left. Over the years, everything quieted. At the time, some in the media tried selling the story of the superstar assisting the newbie. When people talk about Vicks ability as a passer, they often point to the 88-yard, flick-of-the-wrist bomb he threw to DeSean Jackson against Washington in 2010. Any change in the angle of the throw or the trajectory of the ball, and it would have fallen incomplete. Rodgers is tough. Favres blend of mindset, approach and ability made him unlike any quarterback the league has seen. The ball got moving so fast that it almost looked like it was rising by the time it got to his receiver like a great drive in golf that seems to take a hop mid-flight. GP PYDS PCT TDs INT RATING They're the only ones he really trusts. You start questioning everything, he later said. Still, it brings up the question. Favre's taken the Packers to two Super Bowls, winning one, while Rodgers has a Lombardi Trophy following the one trip that he led Green Bay to the championship game. Maximize your sports performance with advice from todays top coaches and elite athletes. (Brett) Favre in the 2009 Monday Night Football game and how electric that was. As far as the Packers losing record, Rodgers cant play defense inaddition to his duties behind center. Coming out of college, Rodgers didn't possess the rocket he does today. Rodgers have been the subject of endless comparisons since Rodgers took over as the starting quarterback in the 2008 season. He lives in Chicago. Many of the most ridiculous throws that Rodgers has ever made have come when hes moving to his left. Aaron, he said, this is yours ., Rodgers wanted to vanish. Since Brett Favre was still the unquestioned starter during that period of time, Rodgers was afforded the opportunity to focus on his development. Otherwise, every signal caller brought to town was there solely to provide support. He wasnt just the team and he wasnt just the city. The reason that Rodgers is so dangerous on those rollouts is that no QB in NFL history has been better at getting back on-balance when hes on the move. Though this doesn't show up on tape as much as the others, it had to be included. Bob Harlan, the team president, initially promoted Sherman to coach and general manager when Ron Wolf left before the 2001 season. He didnt care that it was just the scout team. We've seen this before, with Brett Favre. Through the years, the men signed to back Favre had been a mixed bag of seasoned veterans (Ken OBrien, Jim McMahon, David Klingler, Steve Bono, Tim Couch) and unspectacular-yet-useful youngsters (Ty Detmer, Doug Pederson, Craig Nall). That game, played on Monday night, included John Madden, Favres most vocal public supporter through the years, speaking as if the quarterback were a hapless Muhammad Ali boxing Larry Holmes in their ugly 1980 mismatch. Rodgers has thrown 475 touchdowns while tossing 105 interceptions and the longest pass of his career went for 93 yds. Combining that with a few goofy putts off some scaffolding made for must-see TV. Maybe his agent or someone convinced him he was important, but he walked around like he was the next best thing., Many of the Packers participated in a summer charity softball game in nearby Appleton. You have to compete. The new kids were largely about highlights, headlines, attention. @JoshAllenQB edges out @PatrickMahomes for the strongest arm in #Madden22 @EAMaddenNFL pic.twitter.com/IW7erzZK2r. Brett Favre was the starting quarterback for the Green Bay Packers when the team drafted up and coming sensation Rodgers back in 2005. The 1978 Labour Day Classic was one for the ages.Classic Memories ? He had favorites. Favre is more intense, but had fun with what he did and the team knew that their quarterback was going to control the team. Once again Green Bay wanted a quarterback, but knew the two best available players (Utahs Alex Smith and Californias Aaron Rodgers) would be distant memories once their slot (24th overall) arrived. In his first at bat, Rodgers clubbed a home run and skipped and hopped around the bases. When he launched a 60-yard missile to Mecole Hardman on Monday night while moving backward, no one even blinked. At one point during their day together, Tomlinson asked Rodgers what people had told him about Brett Favre. Just 15 years ago, the Packers were on the board at 24th overall when they selected a quarterback described as "an excellent passer who combines arm strength, mechanics and delivery to make all . He found the quarterback to be phony, arrogant, thin-skinned. As Aaron Rodgers still ponders a decision on his playing future, he says he doesn't want to do what Brett Favre did back in 2008. He didnt know what to say.. Rodgers, almost by design, keeps his right arm fairly close to his body, even when hes trying to put extra zip on the ball. Now shut the fuck up., Rodgers listened to Driverfor all of four seconds. Rodgers was drafted back in 2005 in the first-round of the NFL draft and served as Favre's back-up for three years. All told, Favres 20 touchdown passes were marred by 29 interceptions. If you watch that throw, youll see how Rodgers almost uses his left leg as a peg to stop his momentum rather than taking a long step to add velocity. Build your football workout today! Copyright 2000-2023 Sports Reference LLC. . Favre is 2-2 in NFC Championship games in the Green and Gold; Rodgers is 2-3. It is a work in progress, and our growing teamwelcomes your feedback. But Also Highly Skilled, NFL Beer Prices, Ticket Prices, And Hot Dogs By Team 2023, The Worst $100+ Million Contracts in Baseball History, Beer, Hot Dog, and Ticket Prices For Every NBA Team. Rodgers has surpassed this mark in eight different seasons. You should do the same., It wasnt the easiest day, Rodgers said. My favorite, though, has nothing to do with whos the best either in NFL history or in the game today. If you want to become a better football player, regardless of your position, youll need to develop a high level of conditioning. Rodgers Vs Brady: Regular Season Stats. He hated how the teams notoriously protective PR staff served as his personal brick wall, and laughed as rival journalists left offerings at the shrine of Brett. Brett Favre has lived this. Do you believe that shit? Favre threw more from his hip and delivered the ball with an unnecessary wind-up motion. There are definitely examples of Favre buying time and firing a late throw into traffic for a spectacular touchdown, but while Favre had plenty of memorable ad-libs, most of his best throws came when he had time to wind up and uncork a throw downfield. ALL GAS NO BRAKES #KCvsBAL https://t.co/UDLtYDgm6e pic.twitter.com/Ji2hqX8m2I, Kansas City Chiefs (@Chiefs) September 29, 2020. It would be greatly appreciated and would Brett couldnt believe that, said Craig Nall, the backup quarterback. Until recently, that is. No doubt the main reason for the Green Bay Packers ' success the past 25 years has been Hall of Fame quarterback play with three-time MVP Brett Favre and two-time MVP Aaron Rodgers. The new quarterback approached the old quarterback and uttered what will forever go down as the worst introductory line in the history of professional sports. Favre has some experience being a legendary Packers QB and then . You could tell the guys were not happy. Were he, for example, flushed from the pocket, a coach might blow the whistle for a re-start. When he arrived in camp, Chris Samp, a rookie free agent wide receiver from Winona State, couldnt wait to work with his hero, ol No. Rodgers was Favre's equal when it came to arm strength, and he was already, as a rookie, a far better decision maker. Since then, the Packers have lost on that stage to Seattle (2014), Atlanta (2016) and San Francisco (2019). As opposed to hispredecessor, he's patient and waits for his receivers to gain separation before delivering the ball accurately. While Favre made plenty of throws with pin-point precision, he was rather inconsistent due to a variety of factors. His consecutive starts streak of 297 is a testament to that, and he's the toughest QB ever to play the game, both physically and mentally. This was hardly new terrain for veteran superstars, but Favre was thought to be different. Three games into this resurgent season, I stand by that claim. Frank Winters? Most importantly, strongest arm and best arm are not the same. Rodgers puts it right on Allen Lazard for the 48-yard catch! In addition to off-season lacrosse workouts, youll find plenty of on-the-field drill for all lacrosse positions. However he's still very raw and threw for 20 touchdowns and 17 . Scoring statistics (TD, XP, FG) are complete all-time. Both have built lasting legacies that will be Greg Camarillo? Favre has 43 career game-winning drives, one less than Tom Brady. Please see our Contributors and Sources page for data source details. Hes a fire-breathing dragon who happens to play quarterback. Of the 21 teams picking ahead of Green Bay,12 were about to take a quarterback salary cap hit in excess of $2.4 million for 2005. But alas, the stars have aligned in the most Shakespearian of ways withthe Gunslinger taking on Noodle Arm this weekend with a playoff birthon the line. Not much, Rodgers said. Rodgers have been the subject of endless comparisons since Rodgers took over as the starting . No. Favre and Rodgers is next. Or write about sports? Its not exactly the guru type of throwing that weve seen from some of these guys whove been teaching quarterbacks over the years, Rodgers told STACK. Its something that you have to work on. After the game, he was asked about retirement and again hemmed and hawed. Its no secret Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers didnt start off their relationship on the best of terms. They expected him to be shy and quiet and not try to outshine Brett Favre, the legend. Working on shoulder strength and lifting weights offers upper body strength. In three years, hes already made it to league MVP voting, finishing second behind Aaron Rodgers. Hes not even good. Which was laughablehe was real good.), but the younger players felt his sense of urgency, and responded. Mahomes can do everything. GUNSLINGER: The Remarkable, Improbable, Iconic Life of Brett Favre. Aaron Rodgers vs Brett Favre Stats. The team wasnt the same anymore. The problem, however, was that they were tough to find. That averages out to 27.6 per season in the 16 years he played with the Pack. But after watching hundreds of combined throws from about a dozen different QBs, this really did come down to a three-man race. Factors such as touch, off-platform ability, and improvisational skills were part of the equation.